Did anyone receive odd phone calls about their rental, then find that they were on Craigs List with stolen photos? I had of couple odd calls - people asking unusual questions, and translating for someone else in the background.
Did you contact Craig's list and have them take the ad down?
If I were you, I'd be nervous about a phisher. Check the dashboard and make sure you've been getting all your inquiries and that your email hasn't been hacked. I can just imagine a bold phisher calling you if he gets questions about your house from a potential renter.