Not sure about the broken leg, but the other stuff, all I can say is, it happens. I don't see anything that's a flagrant issue here. The cushion could be suntan oil. The deck could probably be scrubbed. Underwear in the tree? Unless they nailed or glued it into the tree that's not even worth the effort of taking a picture. If that's the worse damage you have from 8, 21 year old boys I'd say you got off pretty easily. Next time put something in your agreement that says you don't rent to anyone younger than 25.
I've seen bigger messes from 3 11 year old boys in one afternoon!
Posting the travelers names would be a violation of Community Guideline:
- Protect the privacy of yourself and others. — Keep personal information about anyone else private; including their names, home addresses, phone numbers and email addresses. We recommend you keep your own information private as well.
HomeAway Community Manager